I just finished watching The Last Jedi a couple of hours ago after having dragged myself through The Rise of Skywalker yesterday and the contrast between the two films is drastic! I’m talking absolute night and day. The Rise of Skywalker feels like an absolute abomination to the franchise as it tears the characters and saga limb from limb while The Last Jedi manages to feel fresh, new, and ultimately, quite satisfying. No, The Last Jedi isn’t perfect but it does have its moments.
As I watched The Last Jedi I noticed the main reason why Finn feels so starkly different in The Rise of Skywalker. In fact, it’s very clear.
Why was Finn such a compelling character in The Force Awakens? Because he was a stormtrooper. It was that simple fact that made him one of the most enduring and unique characters in the franchise. I loved Finn’s story and I was excited to see his arc in the Sequel trilogy.
Even though Rian Johnson left the idea of Finn being Force-sensitive on the back burner one thing he didn’t lose for Finn’s story was the idea that yes, he was a stormtrooper and that deserting the First Order hadn’t suddenly made him a superhero. In fact, he was still very scared at the beginning of the film and his only real reason for staying with the Resistance was so he could wait for Rey and then hopefully jump ship with her.
It was only during the side mission with Rose Tico did he begin to understand what it meant to others being a part of the Resistance and by the end of the film he’s now ready to do anything, even lay down his life, for his friends as a soldier of the Resistance rather than run away.
It was a beautiful evolution in his story and I just knew it was going to end perfectly.
Instead, J.J Abrams forgot this fascinating thread, instead choosing to force a burgeoning Force-sensitive Finn down our throats instead of focusing on his role as a former stormtrooper-turned-Resistance-big-deal for the majority of the movie.
They tried to do that with Jannah being a former stormtrooper as well but Abrams didn’t choose to focus enough on the fact that these were two former troopers fighting back against their oppressors. Instead, he made us forget that emotionally stirring storyline by making us focus on the idea of Finn being Force-sensitive which didn’t feel warranted. It instead felt like another course correct to make fans who hated The Last Jedi happy.
I love Star Wars. I love this franchise’s characters. And boy do I hate the fact that The Rise of Skywalker seemed to totally dismantle a story that I’ve cherished for decades.
Rey is powerful for no reason other than it’s necessary to end the story with the heroes winning, Kylo Ren is a creep who gets a smooch before he dies because they just couldn’t let Ren and Rey not kiss in this trilogy, Poe is annoying and I don’t even know why (oh, and now he’s the Star Wars equivalent of a drug dealer…great…), Finn is now practically a Jedi, Rose is reduced to a nothing role like Jar Jar Binks (she is NOT as annoying as Jar Jar Binks people!) and Palpatine is suddenly the stupidest villain in Star Wars because he told Rey his entire master plan.
And don’t get me started on the forgettable new characters, namely Zorri Bliss who’s just thrust into this story to have a ten-second romance with Poe to make people think he’s not interested romantically in Finn. (Yeah, right.)
Oh, and how they treat C-3PO in this movie is beyond upsetting. Yes, he can be comic relief in The Empire Strikes Back but the characters in The Rise of Skywalker literally treat him badly. It’s as if no one even seems to like him but they only tolerate his existence because he’s the translator. I mean, Poe literally calls him a “metal a**” at one point. Not even Han Solo called him that! It’s terrible!
I think the only characters who were left unscathed was Lando and Leia. And the Millennium Falcon. Lol.
Excuse the rant. When I think about The Rise of Skywalker and how it destroyed something that had been so much fun to watch…I’m just glad The Mandalorian exists because honestly, I would be done with Star Wars right now.
I thank you for reading and I hope you have a great day.
6 thoughts on “The Reason Why Finn’s Story Lost Steam in ‘The Rise of Skywalker’”
Yeah… I don’t know if I’m ever going to get around to thinking The Reek of Skywalker (I found a new way to make fun of its badness) is good. I managed to get there with the prequels. I’m not there with Reek, and I don’t think I’m going to get there. I’ve managed to talk myself out of it ruining the other eight even though it’s not really any better than a Riddick movie (which, while interesting some level, they’re all pretty bad, really), and I think that’s about as good as I’m going to get.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have even started contemplating if the dismal Wonder Woman sequel is better than The Reek of Skywalker. Lol. And I didn’t like WW1984.
To me the moment they killed off Han Solo was where things started going south. Instead of doing something new, the sequel’s are pretty much fan fiction what ifs. I personally do enjoy most of the sequels, yet understand the struggle hard core Star Wars fans feel. I’m hopeful they will bring some of these characters back and fix the mistakes, because the cast for these films was pretty solid.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Super solid. I loved the characters so much that honestly it’s the only reason why I still watch TROS. Daisy Ridley, John Boyega, Adam Driver, and Oscar Isaac were my Mark Hamill, Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher, and David Prowse/James Earl Jones. I hope that in about ten years maybe we can get another film with these actors but honestly, I’m pretty sure they don’t want to come back.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m with you on pretty much all of this. I thought The Last Jedi was way better than The Rise of Skywalker. I didn’t like the way everybody treated C-3PO in TROS. And I have the same problems with Zorii as you do.
The only thing I’ll disagree with is that TROS “forced Force-sensitive Finn down our throats”. They only gave a few hints about Finn being Force-sensitive; if anything, it felt like an underdeveloped storyline.
I agree that part of the problem is having two different directors with two different visions. It would have been better if they’d committed to one story arc for Finn, instead of switching back and forth between the ex-Stormtrooper-turned-Resistance angle and the Force-sensitive angle. Still, the two didn’t need to be at odds. If being Force-sensitive was what made Finn different from the other Stormtroopers in the first place, then they should have been able to tie his Force-sensitivity and his change of allegiance together.
Basically I don’t have a strong opinion one way or the other on Finn being Force-sensitive. I just wish that they’d given him some kind of consistent story.
Incidentally, it’s interesting to compare Finn’s Force-sensitivity in TROS with Leia’s in ROTJ. Both are only hinted at and play a minimal role in the story, yet I can’t help feeling that Leia’s Force-sensitivity was used much more effectively.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Way more effectively in literally two lines.
“I’ know. Somehow…I’ve always known.” or “He wasn’t. I can feel it.” Chills!
LikeLiked by 1 person